Binary and Individuality of Notes as the Basis of Visual Perception of Musical Notation

Abstract:

The article discusses the fundamental concepts of binary and individual coding in musical notation and their significance for visual perception and music education. Binary coding divides notes into two categories—notes on lines and notes in the spaces between them—while individual coding assigns each note within an octave a unique identifier, facilitating the learning process.

The advantages and limitations of both coding methods are analyzed, emphasizing their impact on students' ability to memorize, recognize, and interpret musical text.

The article also analyzes various music education methods and popular piano learning applications, comparing their effectiveness in teaching binary coding. Methods such as the Russian School of Music, Suzuki Method, Solomon Method, Carl Orff Method, and color-coded systems are evaluated based on their approach to teaching the binary structure of musical notation.

Special attention is given to the Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system, which uniquely combine binary and individual approaches to music education. This approach aims to make music literacy more intuitive and accessible, providing a balanced and gradual transition from individual coding to binary.

The article highlights the scientific foundation of the Hiner Method, which optimizes the learning process by considering the physiological and cognitive aspects of visual-motor coordination.

The study emphasizes the importance of integrating these innovative approaches into global music education programs to enhance the effectiveness and accessibility of music learning for students of all ages.

Musical notation is a complex system of symbols that must be perceived and understood by students for successful music learning.

At the core of musical notation lies binary coding—the division of notes into those on lines and those in the spaces between them—and the individuality of each note, which depends on its placement within an octave and its visual characteristics.

These aspects of notation are directly related to how students visually perceive music and how they interpret musical text.

Individual Coding and Its Adherents

Definition: Individual coding is a method of visually or symbolically designating notes and keys, in which each note within one octave has a unique marker (color, symbol, or image) to facilitate the process of memorizing and recognizing notes and sounds for beginners.

Advantages of Individual Coding:

• Simplification of Initial Learning:

  • Individual coding helps students quickly memorize and recognize notes and keys using visual cues. Each note has its unique color or symbol, making the learning process easier for beginners.
  • For example, in early music education methods such as the Suzuki Method and Color Piano, color markers are used to designate notes, making the learning process more accessible and engaging.

• Support for Visual Perception:

  • For visually-oriented students, the use of different colors or symbols can play a key role in learning. Research shows that visual cues can improve memory and information perception (Wichmann et al., 2002).

Limitations of Individual Coding:

• Information Overload:

  • Using too many colors or symbols can overload students' memory, especially if they simultaneously have to keep in mind the binary nature of musical notation. According to George Miller's study, human short-term memory is limited to about 7 plus or minus 2 elements (Miller, 1956).

• Transition to Black-and-White Text:

  • It may be challenging for a beginner to transition from color coding to traditional black-and-white musical text, leading to confusion and complicating the learning process.

Binary Coding and Its Features

Definition: Binary coding is a method of visually designating notes and keys, where notes on lines and notes in the spaces between them have different color or other visual markers. The goal of this coding is to emphasize the binary nature of the musical system, where notes are either on lines or in spaces, and the white piano keys serve as a visual continuation of these lines and spaces.

Advantages of Binary Coding:

• Reflecting the Fundamentals of the Musical System:

  • Binary coding corresponds to the traditional musical system that uses lines and spaces to denote the pitch of notes. This makes it more natural for perception and understandable from the first steps of learning.
  • In traditional musical notation, lines and spaces are clearly divided, helping to quickly distinguish notes and their pitch (Grier, 2021).

• Consistency with Historical Practice:

  • This method aligns with centuries-old practices of using musical notation, facilitating the transition to reading standard black-and-white text. This approach is also supported by studies and publications describing the evolution of musical notation (Encyclopaedia Britannica).

• Simplifying the Learning Process:

  • Beginners quickly understand where the notes and keys are located and can easily memorize their positions thanks to the clear binary structure. The binary structure of the musical system helps to systematize and simplify the process of learning to read notes.
  • Binary coding helps to quickly link the line/space and the sound (key), instantly creating neural nodes between audio, visual, and kinesthetic information. Understanding 10 lines is much easier than matching each note individually to each key. Our vision works in a way that it unifies similar objects. We see a green lawn, not millions of individual blades of grass. This is especially effective if vertical reading is practiced initially, where the beginner's vision simply "slides" along the trajectory from the note to the key.

Explanation vs. Vision: The Difference Between Theoretical Explanation and Sensory Perception of Binary Coding

Understanding binary coding in musical notation can occur in two main ways: through theoretical explanation and through direct vision and sensory perception.

Explaining binary coding assumes that the teacher or educational material presents information in the form of logical conclusions, explaining to the student that notes on lines and spaces represent different elements of the musical system. This approach is based on a rational understanding of the structure of musical notation.

Vision of binary coding is an approach where the student directly sees and feels the binary nature of the note system through visual and tactile channels of perception. Instead of merely understanding the difference between notes on lines and in spaces, the student can observe this difference in practice using auxiliary graphics and other visual and interactive tools. This approach allows for the formation of strong neural connections that link visual and kinesthetic perception with musical information.

Brief Analysis of Existing Methods and Textbooks from the Perspective of Binary Learning

Global music pedagogy offers many methods and educational materials, each with its approach to teaching the binary nature of musical notation. Let’s review the most well-known ones:

Russian School of Music

The Russian School of Music traditionally relies on theoretical explanations of musical concepts. In most cases, beginners learn binary coding through textual and oral explanations, as well as through classical exercises such as solfeggio and playing scales, triads, and chords.

This approach is based on reasoning. The emphasis is on the rational understanding of the musical structure.

Suzuki Method

The Suzuki Method focuses on auditory perception and develops musical perception through listening exercises. Although binary coding is also explained, the main emphasis is on reproducing music by ear. Students develop their skills through repetition and imitation, which can ultimately help them understand the structure of musical notation.

Solomon Method

The Solomon Method uses visual cues and color coding to designate different notes and keys, but the primary emphasis is also on auditory perception. This method uses colors and symbols to simplify the initial stage of learning, but the main focus is on sound perception, which reduces attention to the binary structure of musical text.

Carl Orff Method

The Orff system of music education also focuses on auditory perception and active music-making by ear. Students are involved in musical activities through playing instruments such as xylophones and metallophones, which helps them intuitively understand music. However, as in the Solomon Method, the binary nature of musical text is not the central element of learning. The primary focus is on the practical mastery of musical instruments and rhythms.

Color-Coded Systems

These systems use colors to designate notes and keys, making it easier for beginners to distinguish and memorize musical symbols. However, these systems do not necessarily emphasize the binary placement of notes on lines and spaces. Primarily, they focus on simplifying visual perception and initial stage learning, leaving a deeper understanding of musical notation structure (which students will need in the future) out of the equation.

The Music Tree

In this series of textbooks, students are given the opportunity to see the binary nature of musical text through visual exercises. However, the primary approach is still based on theoretical explanations, although some elements of the textbooks encourage practical perception of binary coding.

John Thompson's Easiest Piano Course

This method emphasizes the understanding and visualization of musical text, including binary coding. Students learn musical notation through exercises that involve an understanding of binary structures, although not always visually supported.

Bastien Piano Basics

This series of textbooks emphasizes the visualization of musical notation and helps students see the connection between notes on lines and spaces and piano keys. However, binary coding is considered more as a theoretical concept than as an object of sensory perception.

Faber Piano Adventures

This method also uses elements of visualization and explanation of binary musical text coding; however, the primary focus is on general music literacy. Beginners develop an understanding of musical notation structure through a series of exercises that emphasize the distinction between notes on lines and spaces.

Analysis of Popular Music and Piano Learning Applications in the Context of Binary Notation Organization

In recent years, many music and piano learning applications have appeared on the market, each offering its approaches to teaching. However, not all of them are based on understanding the binary nature of reading and writing musical notation.

Simply Piano

The application focuses on step-by-step learning, where students gradually learn to play melodies, but binary coding of musical text is not a core element of teaching. More attention is given to repetition and auditory perception.

Yousician

This application emphasizes a game format for learning, where users complete tasks and earn points. However, understanding binary coding in the application is not developed to the proper level, as the primary focus is on the practical reproduction of melodies.

Piano Marvel

The application includes elements that help students understand the structure of musical notation, including binary coding. However, binary coding is viewed more as an additional aspect of learning rather than the foundation of musical perception.

Synthesia

Synthesia is one of the most popular piano learning applications, where notes fall from the top of the screen, and the user is invited to press the corresponding keys on the instrument. However, Synthesia does not focus on teaching binary coding of musical text. Note visualization is done in the form of falling rectangles, which more resembles a game than traditional note reading. Thus, Synthesia does not develop an understanding of binary coding, as beginners do not learn to read musical text in its traditional form.

Piano Wizard

Piano Wizard also uses a game approach to learning, turning notes into colored symbols that match the keys on the musical keyboard. This application includes an element of visualization, but it is more directed towards entertainment than learning to read notes in their binary structure. As with Synthesia, binary coding of musical text is not emphasized, which limits the development of a full understanding of the musical notation system.

Playground Sessions

Playground Sessions offers a lesson structure that includes video instructions and interactive exercises. However, as in the case of Synthesia, the primary focus is on playing popular music rather than studying traditional musical text. The binary nature of the musical system is not the focus of teaching, as the application is oriented towards practical music reproduction rather than reading notes in their classical form.

Skoove

Skoove offers interactive learning, where students learn to play by reading notes displayed on the screen. The application emphasizes reading musical text but not its binary structure. Nevertheless, elements of note reading are present, and the application can help develop a general understanding of musical notation, although it does not delve into binary learning as a primary component of teaching.

Flowkey

Flowkey combines visual note representation and auditory learning, offering users the opportunity to simultaneously see and hear how to play keyboard instruments. However, as with other applications, binary coding of musical text is not a central theme in learning. The emphasis is on practical reproduction of melodies and chords rather than on structural understanding of musical text.

Pianote

Pianote is oriented towards learning to play the piano through video lessons and exercises, but like most other applications, binary coding of musical text does not receive special attention. The primary focus is on developing playing skills and understanding chords, without emphasizing traditional note reading.

Pianolytics

Pianolytics offers a more analytical approach to learning piano, where students can see chords, notes, and their analysis in real-time. Although the application helps users understand the structure of musical compositions, binary coding of musical text is not emphasized. Beginners can develop their note reading skills, but without emphasizing binary understanding of musical notation (which significantly slows the development of their musical literacy).

Soft Mozart System and Hiner Method in the Context of Binary and Individual Coding

The Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system represent a unique combination of binary and individual approaches to music education. This system is designed to simplify the process of mastering musical literacy, making it intuitive and accessible for students of any age. An important aspect of the Hiner Method is the healthy balance and gradual transition between binary and individual coding, which allows for the harmonious development of musical skills.

1. Binary Coding as the Foundation of the Hiner Method

Binary musical notation coding is a fundamental concept of the Hiner Method, where notes are divided into two categories: notes on lines and notes in spaces. In the Soft Mozart system, this binary nature of notes is visually emphasized using color coding:

• Red is used for notes on lines.
• Blue is for notes in spaces.

This color system helps beginners of any age immediately see the binary structure of musical text and understand how it is connected to the white keys of the piano. Notes on lines are easily associated with one group of keys, while notes in spaces are associated with another, simplifying the process of memorization and reproduction.

2. Individual Coding in the Hiner Method

Individual coding also plays an important role in the Hiner Method, especially at the initial stages of learning. Each note is designated with a unique color or symbol, which helps students quickly recognize and memorize notes. This is particularly important for the development of musical ear, voice, and performance technique.

• Development of Ear and Voice: Individual markers help students focus on the sound characteristics of each note, contributing to the development of ear and intonation skills. Students begin to understand how each note sounds and how it should be performed on the instrument or vocally.
• Performance Technique: At the initial stage of learning, when it is important to master basic motor skills and coordination, individual coding makes the process more engaging and comprehensible. Learners can practice piano technique, relying on visual cues, helping them to master the instrument faster with minimal physical strain.

3. Healthy Balance and Gradual Transition in the Use of Codings

The Hiner Method is distinguished from other methodologies by its balanced approach to the use of binary and individual coding. The learning process considers the importance of a gradual transition from one system to another:

• Initial Stage: Students start with more prominent individual coding, helping them to master basic musical concepts and develop ear, voice, and performance technique. This stage is crucial for building a solid foundation in music education.
• Transition to Binary System: As students become more confident, they begin to transition to binary coding. At this stage, they already understand basic musical concepts and are ready for more complex tasks, such as fluent note reading and in-depth understanding of music theory.

4. Technological Support of the Hiner Method

Modern technology plays a key role in supporting the Hiner Method, making the learning process more adaptable and effective. Technology helps to optimize the use of individual and binary coding depending on the level of students' preparation:

• Individual Coding: Visual and interactive elements, such as colored markers and symbols on notes and keys, help students easily navigate the musical text and develop auditory skills. This is especially important for children and beginners who need clear visual guides.
• Binary Coding: As students progress in learning, technology helps to smoothly transition to binary coding. At this stage, they learn to see musical text as a whole, understanding its structure and the connection between notes on lines and spaces.

5. Advantages of the Hiner Method

The combination of binary and individual approaches in the Hiner Method provides several key advantages:

• Harmonious Development: Students develop musical skills comprehensively, starting with individual perception of sounds and transitioning to a holistic perception of musical text. This ensures the harmonious development of musical ear, voice, performance technique, and sight-reading.
• Deep Understanding of Theory: Thanks to binary coding, students gain a better understanding of theoretical aspects of music, such as intervals, chords, alterations, and transposition. This knowledge becomes the foundation for further musical development.
• Path to Fluent Note Reading: The binary system allows students to easily navigate musical text, contributing to the development of fluent note-reading skills and confident performance.

Conclusion

The Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system indeed stand apart in modern music pedagogy. This is not just another method of music education; it is a foundational system based on scientific principles that consider the physiological and psychological characteristics of students' music perception.

Uniqueness of the Hiner Method

The Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system are unique in their approach to music education. They are the only system that uses visual-motor delay measurements to create the most effective learning path. This system has helped to establish an evidence base that confirms that the most optimal path of musical development passes through several stages: from vertical note reading using individual and binary color coding, through intermediate formats, and finally to traditional black-and-white musical text. This approach ensures a smooth transition from the initial level to the advanced, helping students to develop both musical skills and a deep understanding of the logic of musical notation.

Scientific Basis of Music Pedagogy

The Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system form the foundation of scientific music pedagogy, as they not only offer theoretical knowledge but also support it with practical evidence. The use of visual-motor delay data and other physiological indicators creates training that most closely matches the natural processes of perception and information processing by students.

There is no other approach in the world that so thoroughly and comprehensively examines the path of musical development, considering all aspects of visual-motor coordination and cognitive processes. This system not only improves learning outcomes but also transforms the approach to music education, making it more intuitive, effective, and at the same time rational and controllable.

Recommendations for the Music Industry

The Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system deserve the attention of all representatives of the music industry. The introduction of this approach into music textbooks and educational programs worldwide could fundamentally change the process of music education, making it more accessible and effective. This system helps beginners of any age and level of preparation to quickly and enjoyably master musical literacy, making it a universal tool for music education.

Final Conclusion

The Hiner Method and the Soft Mozart system are not only a revolutionary approach to music education but also a method confirmed by scientific research, which provides the most optimal path to musical development. Their introduction into music programs and textbooks worldwide would be a significant step forward in music pedagogy, opening new horizons for learning and creativity.

Hellene Hiner,

Doctor of Musical Arts (DMA) in pedagogy, founder of scientific musical pedagogy.

Bibliography:

Wichmann, F. A., Sharpe, L. T., & Gegenfurtner, K. R. (2002). The contributions of color to recognition memory for natural scenes. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 28(3), 509-520.

Miller, G. A. (1956). The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for processing information. Psychological Review, 63(2).

Grier, J. (2021). The Evolution of Music Notation Systems. Encyclopaedia Britannica.

Hiner Method and Soft Way to Mozart www.softmozart.com

Clark, F., & Goss, L. (2000). The Music Tree. Alfred Music.

Suzuki, S. (1969). Suzuki Violin School. Alfred Music.

Thompson, J. (1937). John Thompson's Easiest Piano Course. Willis Music.

Bastien, J. (1976). Bastien Piano Basics. Kjos Music Company.

Faber, N., & Faber, R. (1993). Piano Adventures. Hal Leonard Corporation.

Simply Piano. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.joytunes.com

Synthesia. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.synthesiagame.com

Piano Wizard. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.pianowizard.com

Playground Sessions. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.playgroundsessions.com

Skoove. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.skoove.com

Flowkey. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.flowkey.com

Pianote. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.pianote.com

Pianolytics. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.pianolytics.com

Alania, August 9, 2024